Is it better to rent or buy in Australia?
There’s no universal answer. Buying builds equity and protects you from rent rises, but comes with big upfront costs (deposit, stamp duty) and ongoing costs that renters don’t pay. Renting keeps your deposit invested and flexible. This calculator compares the two fairly by assuming the renter invests the deposit, stamp duty and any month-to-month savings, while the owner invests any savings once rent would have cost more than owning.
How the comparison works
- The buyer pays the deposit, stamp duty for the selected state (owner-occupier or first home rates) and $3,000 of other costs.
- Each month the buyer pays the mortgage plus ownership costs; the renter pays rent. Whoever spends less invests the difference.
- The buyer’s wealth = home value − 2.5% selling costs − loan balance + their investments. The renter’s wealth = their investment portfolio.
Your home is generally exempt from capital gains tax, while the renter’s investments are taxed – so enter an after-tax return for the renter.
What tips the balance
- Time: stamp duty and selling costs take years to recover. Short timeframes favour renting.
- Price growth vs investment returns: buying wins when the home grows faster than the renter’s portfolio, especially because the home is leveraged.
- Rent-to-price ratio: where rents are low relative to prices (gross yields of 3% or less), renting and investing often comes out ahead.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good rent vs buy break-even?
If buying overtakes renting within 5–7 years under realistic assumptions, buying is usually reasonable for someone who plans to stay put.
Does this include stamp duty?
Yes – it uses the PropertyLens stamp duty calculator for your chosen state, with first home concessions if you tick the box.
What growth rate should I use?
Long-run Australian dwelling price growth has averaged around 5–6% a year in nominal terms over the past 20 years, but future growth may be lower. Try a few scenarios.
Is renting “dead money”?
Not if the money you don’t spend on stamp duty, interest and maintenance is invested. Interest, rates and insurance are “dead money” for owners too.
General information only – not financial, tax or credit advice. Results are estimates from the figures you enter and the simplified assumptions stated on this page. They don’t consider your objectives, financial situation or needs. Talk to a licensed financial adviser, registered tax agent or credit provider before acting.